Idaho’s Decades-Long Practice of Housing Mentally Ill Patients in Prisons Sparks Renewed Criticism and Calls for Change

Idaho's prison-based mental health care
Spread the love

A 50-year Stalemate Ignored on Mental Health Care

Idaho’s mental health institutions are jails where many inmates who are mentally ill are confined, a practice severely criticized as both a violation of their human rights and an inadequate provision of care.

The state is still sticking to this approach despite the long-standing protests of advocates and officials, which means that it may become the only American state which allows non-offending psychiatric patients in prisons.

The Condemned but not Convicted

It has drawn much criticism since it was established in the 1970s. Marilyn Sword for instance was one such voice, who vehemently opposed Idaho’s arrest of “dangerously mentally ill” persons in prisons due to civil rights infringements and further disadvantaging these people.

These warnings have emerged several times across various years with no less than fourteen official notices since 1954 calling for a separate secure mental health unit out of prison walls.

Idaho’s Consistent Opposition and Ignored Advice

Idaho leadership has always defended this as a stop gap measure while promising to provide proper psychiatric hospitals but all those promises never resulted into any tangible outcome.

Recently, there were efforts in the Legislature to allocate money towards funding of a specialized mental health facility but were refused instead choosing to keep patients incarcerated without charges at the state’s maximum-security facility.

Contrary Recommendations from Experts

Idaho’s approach contrasts sharply with national and international guidelines on mental health.

This is against recommendations issued by well-known organizations like Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, American Psychiatric Association, American College of Correctional Physicians, federal courts, United Nations among others.

Keeping mentally ill people locked up in prison for prolonged periods raises ethical concerns and contravenes global standards of care.

Life Imprisonment for Mentally Ill People

Civilly committed psychiatric patients share C Block at Idaho Maximum Security Institution with inmates facing criminal charges and felons having mental illnesses.

Those staying in this place suffer from severe symptoms often including delusions that result in violent actions.

Typically, these periods of isolation last between 110 and 160 days during which no therapeutic conditions are provided for mental health treatment.

Inadequate Care Amid Solitary Confinement

The prisoners involved suffer from extended periods of being alone, lack of access to adequate therapy and are placed in small cells that make their mental conditions worse.

While there is an effort to provide treatment in the prison facility, the structure makes it difficult for them to receive treatment.

This has led to several cases of using force among them pepper spray raising questions about their welfare and recovery process.

Experts argue this practice by Idaho is most likely unconstitutional because it violates ethically accepted standards in health especially when considering individuals with disabilities.

The act of incarcerating people based solely on mental illness without any criminal charges violates basic principles of equality and humane treatments.

A History Marred by Failed Promises

Idaho has been debating the issue of housing mentally ill inmates within correctional institutions since the early part of the 20th century.

There have been intermittent pledges towards having exclusive departments for mental health, but bureaucratic wrangles, financial hitches and political lethargy have stopped any changeover from this harmful system.

The Path of Change That Has Proved to Be Elusive

However, the efforts to put up standalone mental health facilities have been thwarted time and again by bureaucracy and lack of political will.

Proposals for the establishment of special treatment centers have been put on hold leaving the state stuck in a system that is not making any sense for people with mental disorders who need help and rehabilitation.

The Glimmer of Hope

There is good news however, as this recent change of direction from Governor Brad Little has lit a candle of hope for Idaho’s mental health care.

Ideas for constructing dedicated $25 million institutions that provide collaborative mental healthcare outside prison walls have received support.

This suggestion by the Department of Health and Welfare and Corrections could be seen as a sign that non-criminal psych patients will no longer spend long durations in prisons.

Seeking Redemption: A Chance for a New Chapter

At this critical juncture when Idaho is rethinking its approach to mental health care, stakeholders, advocates, and policymakers see this proposed facility as an important step in correcting a historic wrong.

The possibility that we might break away from an outdated system that has lasted over fifty years gives us some confidence that they can hope to receive empathetic attention as well as relevant cure outside cell prisons where they belong.



Spread the love
  • Food Smells Enable Time Travel: Study Finds

    Food Smells Enable Time Travel: Study Finds

    Researchers provided insights into the characteristics of “food memories”.

  • Maternal Depression Affects The Child’s Ability To Speak: Study Finds

    Maternal Depression Affects The Child’s Ability To Speak: Study Finds

    Researchers explored how maternal depression influences a child’s ability to…

  • Spending Time In Blue Spaces Boosts Mental Health: Study Finds

    Spending Time In Blue Spaces Boosts Mental Health: Study Finds

    Researchers explored how spending time in blue spaces boosts mental…

  • Beyond The Potterverse: How Tom Felton’s Mental Health Issues Shed Light On Drug Use

    Beyond The Potterverse: How Tom Felton’s Mental Health Issues Shed Light On Drug Use

    How actor Tom Felton’s autobiography explores his mental health battle…

  • Families Who Eat Together Are Less Stressed, Survey Confirms

    Families Who Eat Together Are Less Stressed, Survey Confirms

    Science provides insights into the psychological benefits of regular mealtimes…

  • Baby Talk Is Similar Across Different Languages: Study Finds

    Baby Talk Is Similar Across Different Languages: Study Finds

    Researchers explored the similarities in baby talk across different languages.

  • Counting Steps Lowers The Risk Of Chronic Diseases: Study Finds

    Counting Steps Lowers The Risk Of Chronic Diseases: Study Finds

    Researchers explored how counting steps reduces the risk of chronic…

  • Children Who Tell Blunt Truths Are Generally Judged Harshly: Study Claims

    Children Who Tell Blunt Truths Are Generally Judged Harshly: Study Claims

    Researchers provide insights into how adults judge children’s habit of…

  • Netflix’s “The Good Nurse” Reveals Charles Cullen’s Mental Illness

    Netflix’s “The Good Nurse” Reveals Charles Cullen’s Mental Illness

    Besides glimpses into a serial killer’s psychology, Netflix’s The Good…

  • Do Women Have A Better Vocabulary Than Men? Surprising Study Finds

    Do Women Have A Better Vocabulary Than Men? Surprising Study Finds

    Researchers examined the gender differences in cognitive abilities between men…

  • The Fear Of Negative Outcomes Decreases When You Are Aware Of Potential Dangers: Study

    The Fear Of Negative Outcomes Decreases When You Are Aware Of Potential Dangers: Study

    Researchers shed light on the psychology behind the fear of…

  • Does Photo-Taking Help Students Better Remember Online Lessons?

    Does Photo-Taking Help Students Better Remember Online Lessons?

    Researchers explored whether photo-taking helps students remember information better in…

  • The Inspiring Story Of Matthew Perry’s Addiction And Recovery

    The Inspiring Story Of Matthew Perry’s Addiction And Recovery

    How actor Matthew Perry’s new memoir chronicled his victory over…

  • Does Reducing Screen Time Make You More Productive?

    Does Reducing Screen Time Make You More Productive?

    American researchers explored the association between reducing screen time and…

  • Sedentary Lifestyle: Effects Of Social Interactions On Physical Activity

    Sedentary Lifestyle: Effects Of Social Interactions On Physical Activity

    Researchers examined how social interactions influence physical fitness.

  • Learning How To Learn Makes You Less Forgetful: Study Finds

    Learning How To Learn Makes You Less Forgetful: Study Finds

    Researchers provide insights into the effectiveness of the spacing and…

  • Dogs Can Smell Stress In Humans: Study Finds

    Dogs Can Smell Stress In Humans: Study Finds

    Researchers provided insights into how dogs can smell stress in…

  • Mental Health Of Housewives In India: The Uknown Facts

    Mental Health Of Housewives In India: The Uknown Facts

    Experts delve into the poor mental health experienced by homemakers…

  • Are Halloween and Mental Health Stigma Linked?

    Are Halloween and Mental Health Stigma Linked?

    Experts debate the association between Halloween and mental health.

  • Can A Stressful Job Make You Depressed?

    Can A Stressful Job Make You Depressed?

    Researchers explored the mental health effects of stressful jobs and…

  • Is It Beneficial To Eat Fruits For Mental Health?

    Is It Beneficial To Eat Fruits For Mental Health?

    Researchers explored how eating fruits for mental health can yield…

  • Did You Know News Addiction Damages Mental Health?

    Did You Know News Addiction Damages Mental Health?

    Researchers explored the ill effects of internet news addiction.

  • Do High-Fat Diets Shrink The Brain? Study Reveals

    Do High-Fat Diets Shrink The Brain? Study Reveals

    Researchers explored the long-term consequences of high-fat diets.

  • Why Emotion Regulation In Schizophrenia Is So Difficult? Study Finds

    Why Emotion Regulation In Schizophrenia Is So Difficult? Study Finds

    Research provides insights into emotion regulation abnormalities in schizophrenia.

  • Can PTSD Service Dogs Improve Mental Health In Military Veterans?

    Can PTSD Service Dogs Improve Mental Health In Military Veterans?

    Researchers explore how service dogs improve mental health conditions in…

  • How To Soothe A Crying Baby? New Study Reveals

    How To Soothe A Crying Baby? New Study Reveals

    Researchers explored effective ways to soothe a crying baby, especially…

  • Hustle Culture: Why We Should Stop Idolizing The “Rise And Shine” Mindset?

    Hustle Culture: Why We Should Stop Idolizing The “Rise And Shine” Mindset?

    Experts highlight the mental health effects of hustle culture.