California’s CARE Courts: When Mental Health Care Meets Civil Rights

CARE Courts
Spread the love

California’s CARE Courts represent a bold and contentious step forward in the ongoing struggle to address mental health and homelessness.

Heidi Sweeney’s journey through the labyrinth of mental illness led her to a place where hallucinations dictated her reality. Under the influence of these haunting voices, she sought refuge amidst the vibrant backdrop of Huntington Beach in Orange County, California, believing it to be her sanctuary.

Amidst beachgoers playing volleyball and cruising on their bikes, she slept in homeless encampments and, later, beside a liquor store, attempting to drown out the cacophony of voices that only she could hear with vodka.

For years, Heidi rebuffed offers of assistance, adamantly declaring, “I’m not sick,” to anyone who extended a helping hand. It wasn’t until law enforcement arrested her for petty theft and public drunkenness that she faced an ultimatum from a judge: jail or treatment. Reluctantly, she chose treatment.

Reflecting on that critical juncture, Heidi expressed profound gratitude for the intervention. “I needed that,” she acknowledged. “I think there are others out there who need it too.”

Heidi firmly believes that without the push towards treatment, she might not be alive today, back at work, and reunited with her husband. Her experience underscores the importance of California’s forthcoming civil CARE (Court Assessment Referral and Engagement) Courts, set to launch in eight counties this fall, including San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Orange. The program will expand statewide in 2024.

Under this novel system, family members and first responders gain the authority to petition county judges to mandate treatment for individuals with psychotic illnesses, even if they are not homeless or have not committed a crime.

The judge will then assess whether the individual meets the program’s criteria and may oversee a care agreement or enforce a treatment plan, including involuntary commitment if deemed necessary.

The legislative bill that established this program received overwhelming support in the state legislature last year, reflecting mounting frustration among voters concerning California’s escalating homelessness crisis.

Nevertheless, it encountered fierce opposition from disability rights organizations, which argued that CARE Courts’ core tenet—compelling individuals who have committed no wrongdoing to undergo mental health treatment—constitutes a violation of civil rights.

This tension between those advocating for voluntary treatment and those contending that the status quo condemns individuals to perish on the streets while preserving their civil liberties is a pervasive theme throughout California.

Orange County officials, in particular, face the daunting challenge of persuading individuals to embrace care without resorting to coercion, especially when the nature of their illness convinces them that they are not unwell.

The CARE Court initiative underscores the profound complexities inherent in addressing mental health issues, particularly when individuals with severe psychotic disorders refuse assistance due to their distorted perception of reality.

The program’s aim is to bridge the gap between compassion and coercion, offering a lifeline to those who may not recognize the gravity of their condition or the necessity of treatment.

One of the central tenets of CARE Courts is the inclusion of family members and first responders in the process. Their involvement enables them to intervene when they encounter individuals in crisis, facilitating access to assessment and treatment.

For family members who have watched their loved ones suffer while their pleas for help went unheeded, this program represents a ray of hope.

Critics, however, argue that the program’s foundation in compulsion threatens civil liberties and raises ethical concerns. They contend that the involuntary nature of treatment violates individuals’ rights and autonomy.

Striking a balance between preserving civil liberties and ensuring that those in dire need of care receive it is a formidable challenge, one that will likely continue to spark debates and legal battles.

The program embodies a fundamental question: How can society extend a compassionate hand to individuals who may be unable to recognize their own suffering?

Finding answers to this question will require ongoing dialogue, adaptation, and a commitment to protecting both individual rights and public welfare.


Spread the love
  • Psychedelic Drug Therapy Can Treat Alcoholism, Study Finds

    Psychedelic Drug Therapy Can Treat Alcoholism, Study Finds

    Researchers showed how psychedelic drug therapy can be used to…

  • Sleep Loss And Generosity Are Linked, Study Finds

    Sleep Loss And Generosity Are Linked, Study Finds

    Researchers examined the link between sleep loss and generosity.

  • People See You As More Attractive Than You Think Your Are, Study Finds

    People See You As More Attractive Than You Think Your Are, Study Finds

    Researchers explored how people see you as more attractive than…

  • Our Friends And Family Evaluate Our Relationships More Accurately Than Us, Study Finds

    Our Friends And Family Evaluate Our Relationships More Accurately Than Us, Study Finds

    Researchers explored how romantic partners incorrectly predict their relationship’s stability,…

  • Is America Getting Mentally “Sicker”? Statistics Affirm The Grim Reality.

    Is America Getting Mentally “Sicker”? Statistics Affirm The Grim Reality.

    Researchers and experts resort to statistics to lay bare the…

  • Playfulness Between Romantic Partners  Makes Relationships Last Longer: Study

    Playfulness Between Romantic Partners Makes Relationships Last Longer: Study

    Researchers explore the link between humor and longevity in romantic…

  • Listening To Classical Music Improves Memory, Study Finds

    Listening To Classical Music Improves Memory, Study Finds

    Researchers explored the link between listening to classical music and…

  • Self-Estimates Of Intelligence Is Higher In Men Compared To Women: Study

    Self-Estimates Of Intelligence Is Higher In Men Compared To Women: Study

    There are gender differences in self-estimates of intelligence. Men think…

  • How Netflix’s Blonde Highlights Marilyn Monroe’s Mental Health Struggles

    How Netflix’s Blonde Highlights Marilyn Monroe’s Mental Health Struggles

    How pop culture continues to shed light on actor Marilyn…

  • Laughter With Friends Differs From Laughter With Romantic Partners: Study

    Laughter With Friends Differs From Laughter With Romantic Partners: Study

    Researchers provide interesting insights into the science of laughter.

  • Couples Look Alike In Happier, Long-term Relationships

    Couples Look Alike In Happier, Long-term Relationships

    Researchers explored the link between couples’ facial resemblance and quality…

  • Is Mom Rage A Serious Mental Health Issue? Science Says Yes.

    Is Mom Rage A Serious Mental Health Issue? Science Says Yes.

    Researchers provide insights into “mom-rage” and recommend measures to address…

  • Use Of Gestures In Speech Therapy Spells Wonders For People With Language Disorders: Study

    Use Of Gestures In Speech Therapy Spells Wonders For People With Language Disorders: Study

    Researchers demonstrated how gestures can improve communication in people with…

  • Research Reveals How Positive Or Negative Memories Are Made

    Research Reveals How Positive Or Negative Memories Are Made

    Researchers studied the brain chemical that makes a memory positive…

  • Is The Blue Zone Lifestyle A Secret To A Healthier And Longer Life?

    Is The Blue Zone Lifestyle A Secret To A Healthier And Longer Life?

    Spread the love The “Blue Zone” includes five regions around…

  • Women With A Higher Voice Pitch Appear Younger, Study Claims

    Women With A Higher Voice Pitch Appear Younger, Study Claims

    Researchers explored how a higher voice pitch can influence the…

  • Racial Discrimination Affects Brain, Study Reveals

    Racial Discrimination Affects Brain, Study Reveals

    Researchers provided insights into how racial discrimination causes changes in…

  • Knowledge Overconfidence Fuels Anti-Scientific Views, Study Finds

    Knowledge Overconfidence Fuels Anti-Scientific Views, Study Finds

    Researchers examined the link between knowledge overconfidence and anti-scientific views.

  • How Physical And Mental Activity Affect Thinking Skills In Men And Women?

    How Physical And Mental Activity Affect Thinking Skills In Men And Women?

    Researchers explored how mental activities affect men and women differently.

  • Why Gender Pay Gap Remains Worst For Women? Study Finds

    Why Gender Pay Gap Remains Worst For Women? Study Finds

    Researchers studied the link between unpaid household work and gender…

  • Kids Who Resist Temptation Enjoy Better Life Success: Study

    Kids Who Resist Temptation Enjoy Better Life Success: Study

    Researchers explore the link between cultural upbringing and self-control in…

  • Is Tom Holland On Social Media Break For Mental Health?

    Is Tom Holland On Social Media Break For Mental Health?

    Experts reveal why we should take a break from social…

  • Frequent Naps May Raise Your Risk Of Stroke: Study

    Frequent Naps May Raise Your Risk Of Stroke: Study

    Researchers explore the link between frequent napping and cardiovascular diseases.

  • Was Jennette Mccurdy In A Toxic Mother-Daughter Relationship?

    Was Jennette Mccurdy In A Toxic Mother-Daughter Relationship?

    iCarly actor Jennette McCurdy’s memoir spills the beans about a…

  • Why Do Girls Believe Brilliance Is A Male Trait? Study Reveals

    Why Do Girls Believe Brilliance Is A Male Trait? Study Reveals

    Researchers explored the link between parental influence and children’s gendered…

  • High-Potency Cannabis Use May Cause Severe Mental Disorders: Study

    High-Potency Cannabis Use May Cause Severe Mental Disorders: Study

    Researchers explored how high-potency cannabis use is linked to addiction…

  • How Do Parent’s Drinking Habits Raise Risk Of Junk Food Addiction In Kids?

    How Do Parent’s Drinking Habits Raise Risk Of Junk Food Addiction In Kids?

    Researchers explored how parents’ drinking habits influenced their children’s addiction…