Fact vs Fiction: Tom Holland’s The Crowded Room Presents A Distorted View of Dissociative Identity Disorder 

DID in The Crowded Room An Incorrect Portrayal featured
Spread the love

Tom Holland made headlines recently when he announced his decision to take a break from acting for a year to focus on his mental health. This news came as a surprise to his fans, especially considering his challenging role as Danny Sullivan, a person with DID in The Crowded Room (Apple TV, 2023). The show, which received negative reviews and failed to create a significant impact, initially didn’t seem to warrant such a decision.

However, several reviews hinted at a major twist in Episode 7, which has since become common knowledge. The twist reveals that Danny Sullivan is a host in a Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) system, and the crimes attributed to him were actually committed by his alternate identities, known as “alters.”

Characters that viewers believed to be Danny’s friends and protectors turned out to be manifestations of his internal life. In later episodes, these alters would “front,” altering Danny’s accent, posture, and entire personality.

This twist may not have been as surprising to those familiar with the real-life case of Billy Milligan, a serial rapist who pleaded insanity due to DID and was found not guilty.

The show loosely draws inspiration from Daniel Keyes’ book, “The Minds of Billy Milligan”, which is acknowledged in the opening credits. Consequently, the late twist lost some of its intended shock value. Unfortunately, it follows a pattern where fictional portrayals of dissociative identity disorder tend to associate it with violence and danger, perpetuating a misrepresented narrative.

Kelly Caniglia, a board member of the non-profit organization An Infinite Mind, which supports individuals with DID, expressed her concerns about the misrepresentation of DID in Tom Holland’s movie. Writing for Inverse, she explains that the media often misrepresents DID, causing her to approach any media related to it with skepticism.

According to Caniglia, DID is a trauma response where an individual’s memories, feelings, and traits become fragmented and distributed among multiple identities. She emphasizes that it is more prevalent than people realize, with 1.5% of the population living with the disorder, surpassing the number of redheads. To romanticize or sensationalize such a crippling mental health condition only serves to escalate the stigmatization of the disorder.

To their credit, the film makers claim to have approached the portrayal of DID in The Crowded Room responsibly. Tom Holland, in an interview, mentioned that they extensively researched the subject, including reading relevant books, articles, and speaking with experts and specialists.

Caniglia acknowledges some elements in the show that demonstrate this research, such as the depiction of Danny’s internal space as the “crowded room,” where his alters convene and discuss their actions. However, she remains critical of the show’s treatment of the disorder as a narrative twist, rather than an integral part of the character.

Holland defends the choice, highlighting the importance of understanding that Danny’s identity extends beyond his DID. He expresses the desire for audiences to get to know Danny as a human being before making assumptions about his mental health condition.

Caniglia finds the twist predictable and believes that there are numerous aspects of DID that remain widely misunderstood. She suggests that the show could have included a disclaimer or used its prominent platform to raise awareness about the disorder beyond its violent stereotypes.

Caniglia points to other works that challenge these stereotypes, such as Dylan Crumpler’s short film, Petals of a Rose, and Marvel’s series, Moon Knight, which portray individuals with DID in a more positive light. These examples provide the population with much-needed representation and break away from the harmful archetypes perpetuated by previous portrayals.

While The Crowded Room‘s multiple-personality disorder case presents a compelling story and attempts to depict DID as a self-preservation mechanism, it ultimately reinforces harmful stereotypes.

Caniglia stresses the importance of representation, particularly for a marginalized population already facing stigmatization. She believes that although the show is entertaining and has its moments of excellence, it continues to perpetuate the dangerous rhetoric associating mental illness, in this case, DID, with violence.


Spread the love
  • Can Feeling Poorer Than Your Friends Impact Your Mental Health?

    Can Feeling Poorer Than Your Friends Impact Your Mental Health?

    Research explores how a sense of socio-economic inequality harms friendships…

  • A Novel Test To Detect Alzheimer’s Disease 3.5 Years Before Clinical Diagnosis

    A Novel Test To Detect Alzheimer’s Disease 3.5 Years Before Clinical Diagnosis

    Research provides insights into a new test formulated to detect…

  • Adult Children 4 Times More Likely To Undergo Family Estrangement: Study

    Adult Children 4 Times More Likely To Undergo Family Estrangement: Study

    Research provides insights into intergenerational relationships.

  • Study Reveals Why Musicians Are More Desirable Dates

    Study Reveals Why Musicians Are More Desirable Dates

    Research explored why musicians are more desirable dates to both…

  • The Dark Side of Consumerism: How Valentine’s Day Can Affect Mental Health?

    The Dark Side of Consumerism: How Valentine’s Day Can Affect Mental Health?

    Experts opine on the link between the commercialization of Valentine’s…

  • Parental Income Influences The Sexual Behavior Of Children: Study Finds

    Parental Income Influences The Sexual Behavior Of Children: Study Finds

    Research explores the long-term impact of parental income on children’s…

  • Did You Know Psychological Flexibility Makes You Less Materialistic?

    Did You Know Psychological Flexibility Makes You Less Materialistic?

    Research delves into the link between psychological flexibility and attachment…

  • Physical Attractiveness Brings Meaning To Our Lives: Study

    Physical Attractiveness Brings Meaning To Our Lives: Study

    Research explored how self-perceptions of physical attractiveness influence “meaningful” lives.

  • Did You Know TikTok Use Triggers Body Dissatisfaction In Women?

    Did You Know TikTok Use Triggers Body Dissatisfaction In Women?

    Research delves into the link between TikTok use and body…

  • What Are Valentine’s Day Blues And How Does It Affect Our Mental Health?

    What Are Valentine’s Day Blues And How Does It Affect Our Mental Health?

    Research delves into the mental health realities of Valentine’s Day…

  • Spanking Hampers Children’s Mental Health: Study Finds

    Spanking Hampers Children’s Mental Health: Study Finds

    Research delves into the negative impact of spanking on children’s…

  • Do Women Prefer Men With Tougher Facial Features? Research Finds

    Do Women Prefer Men With Tougher Facial Features? Research Finds

    Researchers explored how women, when faced with uncertainty, are attracted…

  • Couples Working From Home Together Share Family Tasks Equally: Study

    Couples Working From Home Together Share Family Tasks Equally: Study

    Research explores how dual-income couples approach domestic labor.

  • Visual Food Cues Affect Our Food Choices: Study Finds

    Visual Food Cues Affect Our Food Choices: Study Finds

    Research explored how visual food cues influence our eating behavior.

  • Victims Of Workplace Bullying Are Highly Likely To Believe In Conspiracy Theories: Study

    Victims Of Workplace Bullying Are Highly Likely To Believe In Conspiracy Theories: Study

    Research explores the link between workplace bullying and conspiracy theories.

  • Does Talking To Strangers Benefit Your Mental Health? Experts Opine.

    Does Talking To Strangers Benefit Your Mental Health? Experts Opine.

    Experts opine on the mental health benefits of talking to…

  • Does Tart Cherry Juice Help With Memory? Study Finds

    Does Tart Cherry Juice Help With Memory? Study Finds

    Research confirms the mental health benefits of tart cherry juice.

  • Can Talking To Strangers Help With Depression?

    Can Talking To Strangers Help With Depression?

    Research delves into the mental health benefits of talking to…

  • Partying With A Purpose: Are There Mental Health Benefits Of Celebrations?

    Partying With A Purpose: Are There Mental Health Benefits Of Celebrations?

    Research confirms the mental health benefits of celebrations.

  • False Memories: Why Do Psychopaths Forget Negative Events?

    False Memories: Why Do Psychopaths Forget Negative Events?

    Research provides insights into false memory formation in psychopaths.

  • Parents’ Political Ideology Impacts How Their Children Punish Others: Study

    Parents’ Political Ideology Impacts How Their Children Punish Others: Study

    Research explores how political ideologies and group perceptions get transmitted…

  • Research Reveals How Stress Affects Romantic Relationships

    Research Reveals How Stress Affects Romantic Relationships

    Research delves into the negative impact of stress on our…

  • Cooking Therapy: Why Is Cooking Good For Mental Health?

    Cooking Therapy: Why Is Cooking Good For Mental Health?

    Research reveals the therapeutic effect of cooking and the mental…

  • Parenting Stress Linked To Attachment Insecurity In Young Adults: Study

    Parenting Stress Linked To Attachment Insecurity In Young Adults: Study

    Research explores the link between parenting stress and attachment insecurity.

  • Can Fewer Working Hours Boost Your Life Satisfaction? Study Finds

    Can Fewer Working Hours Boost Your Life Satisfaction? Study Finds

    Research delves into the benefits of fewer working hours.

  • Youth Who Think They Are More Attractive Are Likely To Engage In Offending Behavior: Study Finds

    Youth Who Think They Are More Attractive Are Likely To Engage In Offending Behavior: Study Finds

    Research explains the link between self-perceptions of attractiveness and offending…

  • Believing In No Sense Of Control On Future Boosts Self-Esteem For Introverts: Study

    Believing In No Sense Of Control On Future Boosts Self-Esteem For Introverts: Study

    Research delves into the link between anticipatory stress and self-esteem…